Peppermint Lip Balm vs. Lip Balm #1: Which to Pick?
By Primally Pure | Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Comparisons
Compare Peppermint Lip Balm and Lip Balm #1 from Primally Pure. Learn the key differences in ingredients and hydration to choose the best lip balm for your dry, chapped lips.
Quick answer
Choose Peppermint Lip Balm for deep, long-lasting hydration with grass-fed tallow and a cooling sensation; choose Lip Balm #1 for a lighter, scented option with a few nourishing ingredients.
Ingredient depth vs. simplicity
Peppermint Lip Balm is formulated with grass-fed tallow, beeswax, cocoa butter, and mango butter—ingredients known for deep conditioning and locking in moisture. This makes it a powerhouse for healing and hydrating dry, chapped lips.
Lip Balm #1 takes a simpler approach, using only a few nourishing ingredients. It's available in 5 delicious scents, making it a lighter option for everyday maintenance when your lips aren't severely dry.
Scent and sensory experience
Peppermint Lip Balm offers a refreshing, cooling sensation that can feel invigorating, especially in colder months or when you want a wake-up call for your lips.
Lip Balm #1 provides variety with 5 scent options, allowing you to match your mood or preference. This makes it a more versatile choice if you like switching up your lip balm experience.
Hydration level and lasting power
Peppermint Lip Balm is designed to restore long-lasting moisture, making it ideal for lips that need intensive care. The combination of butters and tallow creates a protective barrier that keeps hydration locked in.
Lip Balm #1, with its simpler formula, offers a smooth and healthy feeling but may require more frequent reapplication for very dry lips. It's best suited for mild dryness or as a daily balm.
How to choose between them
- Choose Peppermint Lip Balm if...: Your lips are chronically dry, chapped, or in need of deep repair. The grass-fed tallow and rich butters provide intensive, long-lasting hydration.
- Choose Lip Balm #1 if...: You want a lightweight, everyday balm with a pleasant scent. It's perfect for maintaining healthy lips without the heavy feel of a treatment balm.
- Consider your scent preference: Peppermint Lip Balm offers a single, cooling peppermint scent. Lip Balm #1 gives you 5 scent options to choose from, offering more variety. If you love variety, Lip Balm #1 is the better pick. If you want a functional, invigorating scent, go with Peppermint.
Product facts at a glance
- Peppermint Lip Balm: Formulated with grass-fed tallow, beeswax, cocoa butter, and mango butter to heal and hydrate dry, chapped lips while restoring long-lasting moisture. This rich blend deeply conditions and locks in hydration, making it a top choice for severely chapped lips that need intensive repair.
Peppermint Lip Balm - Lip Balm #1: Available in 5 delicious scents with only a few nourishing ingredients for a smooth and healthy feeling that lasts. The minimalist formula and variety of scents make it a versatile daily balm for those who prefer simplicity and choice over heavy conditioning.
Lip Balm #1
Which one fits you?
Best for
- People with severely dry, chapped lips needing intensive hydration (Peppermint Lip Balm)
- Those who prefer a lightweight, scented daily balm for maintenance (Lip Balm #1)
Not ideal for
- People who dislike a cooling sensation or strong peppermint scent (avoid Peppermint Lip Balm)
- Those who need deep, all-day moisture without reapplication (avoid Lip Balm #1 for very dry lips)
